Editorial Board Structure, Governance, and Roles Policy of IDJP
Editorial Board IDJP
The editorial board of IDJ Pakistan is responsible for development of policies and procedures, monitoring and oversight of scientific review process and publication of the journal under the leadership of the Editor.
The Editorial Board and Editor shall exercise full editorial independence in all decisions related to manuscript evaluation, acceptance, rejection, and publication, without influence from journal owner (MMIDSP), sponsors, institutions, or external bodies.
Structure
- The editorial board of IDJP consists of the Editor-in-Chief (EIC), managing editor and associate editors.
- All editorial board members report to the EIC.
- The Editorial Board of IDJP can appoint up to 15 members. Addition of further members is subject to approval by the EIC and Editorial board to ensure subject-matter coverage, geographic diversity, and representation of key subspecialties within infectious diseases and microbiology justified by journal scope and workflow.
- The Editorial Board conducts at least bimonthly meetings of all board members to discuss policies and procedures.
- EIC is entitled to call a meeting of the editorial board apart from these regular meetings.
- The Editorial board can make modifications to existing policies and develop new policies and procedures for the journal’s benefit. EIC will review the modifications and new policies and these will be formally ratified by the MMIDSP Executive Committee.
- The Editorial board members may serve as reviewers on papers pertaining to their subject areas.
- It is expected that the editorial board members strictly adhere to the standards set by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) guidelines, which govern manuscript submissions for biomedical journals. (These guidelines can be accessed at: http://www.icmje.org/).
- In line with directions of Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan the Editorial board members cannot publish articles/ commentaries etc in the journal except invited editorials as requested by the EIC
Selection Criteria/ Process for Editorial Board members
- The journal's Editorial Board members are selected based on their profound expertise across various biomedical science disciplines. Individuals with demonstrated interest in publication activities may self-nominate. All appointments are subject to the final approval of the EIC
- Members with PhD degrees in relevant fields (i.e., area of publication) or FCPS/FRCS/MCPS degree for medical journals and strong research and publications background are eligible to join the journal’s Editorial board.(HEC policy 2025 https://www.hec.gov.pk/english/services/faculty/journals/Documents/HEC%20Journals%20and%20Publication%20Policy%202024-As%20amended%20wef%2005-11-2025.pdf )
- In addition to academic qualifications, EBM must demonstrate experience in peer review, familiarity with publication ethics (COPE/ICMJE), and willingness to actively contribute to editorial activities.
- Invitation to join the editorial board are sent by the EIC which should be received and signed for the period of the contract.
- All positions in the Editorial Board are completely voluntary, and no benefits should be expected in return.
- The Editorial Board of IDJP undergoes a renewal every 3 years at least.
- The renewal shall be based on documented performance indicators, including manuscript handling, meeting attendance, peer-review contribution, and adherence to ethical standards. This will involve removing some individuals, inviting others, and renewing some existing members for another term. It is important when inviting a Board member that this issue of term of office is included in the invitation letter to avoid any misunderstandings that can arise. When their term ends it is normal to thank them for their contribution to the journal.
TORs for Editorial Board Members
Editor-in-Chief
Selection Process
The EIC of the journal maintains full responsibility and final authority over all published editorial content. The process for selecting the EIC involves an election at the Annual General Body Meeting of MMIDSP for a three-year term. Candidacy is open to senior faculty members in infectious diseases or microbiology who are members of MMIDSP, with self-nominations being accepted.
Term of contract:
- 3 years renewable after mutual agreement and negotiation with MMIDSP Executive Committee.
- The EIC may step down before the completion of tenure due to personal/ professional reasons at any time. A notice period of three months must be served so a new EIC can be appointed.
Roles and Responsibilities
The EIC shall provide strategic leadership to continuously enhance the journal’s scientific quality, visibility, and operational standards; formulate and implement short- and long-term plans for the journal's sustainable growth; and represent the journal at national and international academic, scientific, and professional forums to promote its standing and outreach.
- Has the final authority for all editorial decisions, including acceptance or rejection.
- Ensures editorial independence, integrity, and adherence to journal policies.
- Oversees resolution of ethical issues and complaints, as per COPE flowcharts.
- Responsible for journal development and improvement in standards
- Should engage in journal promotion
- Responsible for appointment of managing editors and editors
- Responsible for arranging regular editorial board meetings
- Responsible for selection of reviewers, addition of new reviewers and removal of existing reviewers after approval of editorial board members
- Indexing and compliance with PMDC and HEC standards is also managed by editor with the help of the managing editor
- Involved in all Human Resource and hiring related to the journal
- Facilitate and oversee the audit and yearly report to the MMIDSP Executive Committee.
Managing Editor
- Appointed by the EIC
- Minimum qualification: Master’s degree
- Tenure 3 years (renewable)
- Not a voluntary position - salary at comparable market rates
Roles and Responsibilities
The Managing Editor (ME) is involved in managing (handling) an article from submission to first / final decision.
- Responsible for daily operations of the journal
- Conducts initial administrative screening to ensure completeness of submission files (author forms, ethics approval, fee receipt, etc.).
- Returns incomplete submissions to authors for correction before further processing.
- Invites appropriate peer reviewers after recommendations from EIC
- Ensures that all editorial actions comply with COPE and ICMJE ethical standards.
- Responsible for formatting, grammar, and technical consistency after acceptance.
- Prepares final galley proofs and coordinates author approval before publication.
- Manages the communication with reviewers, editorial board and authors
- Responsible for journal’s indexing process and communication with HEC and PM&DC
- Responsible for plagiarism checks on submission
- Responsible to offer the author an overview of any feedback,
- ME will have three or four groups of people to contact on a regular basis: a) the publisher, b) the authors c) the reviewers and d) production team who manage the publication side of the journal.
- ME will work with the editor to agree which articles to place in each issue, ensure that agreed number of pages per issue (especially if paper based) are not exceeded and send editor information concerning all articles in their various stages of the editorial process.
- ME will serve as the Contact for any journal inquiry.
- ME is responsible for setting schedules and internal communications with other staff (editors, reviewers, designers, publishers etc)
- Manages the budget under the supervision of Editorial boards.
- Experienced in Journal Editorial Operations, or academic publishing, manuscript handling, or peer-review coordination
- Familiar with Online Journal System, manuscript workflows from submission to publication, copyediting and proof management
- Must be trained in Publication Ethics (ICMJE / COPE / WAME / HEC / PM&DC)
- Proficient in similarity detection software (Turnitin/iThenticate), reference management system, DOI registration and metadata handling (CrossRef)
- Possess strong written and verbal communication in English to effectively liaise with authors, reviewers, editors, publishers and indexers.
- Good organizational skills to meet the editorial timelines
Editors
- Appointed by the EIC with the approval of the Editorial Advisory Board.
- A postgraduate qualification in a relevant discipline (FCPS / PhD / MD / MPH) in infectious diseases, Medical microbiology, Epidemiology, Public Health.
- Reports directly to the EIC
- Tenure 3 years (renewable)
- Voluntary position
- Willing to declare annual conflicts of interest and recuse when appropriate
Roles and Responsibilities:
- Works with the EIC to oversee a portfolio of submissions, guiding them through the review lifecycle.
- Identify, invite, and manage expert reviewers, ensuring timely and quality feedback.
- Assess manuscript quality, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, and relevance to the journal's scope.
- Analyze reviewer comments, provide their own recommendations (accept, revise, reject). Final Decision is the power lying with only EIC.
- Communicate decisions, offer constructive feedback, and guide authors through revisions.
- Ensure a fair, ethical, and efficient review process
- Advise on strategic direction, suggest special issue themes, invite new board members, and act as an ambassador for the journal.
- Provides editorial support to the EIC and ME
- Reviews the final proof of the journal issue
- Contributes to editorial board meetings
- Maintains confidentiality of journal related issues
- Able to critically appraise the scientific communication, familiar with research reporting guidelines (CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA, STARD, CARE)
- Upholds scientific merit and ethical and publishing guidelines under COPE and ICMJE
Reviewers
- Reviewers are selected based on established competence in relevant scientific domains.
- Experience demonstrated through publications and academic contributions.
- Authors who have published in the journal may be invited to review.
- The journal may post Call for Reviewers notices on its website.
- Interested experts may submit credentials for inclusion in the reviewer database.
- Reviewers may be recognized through certificates, letters of appreciation, or acknowledgments for outstanding performance.
Roles and Responsibilities
- Reviewers should ensure strict confidentiality of all manuscript content and avoid using unpublished data for personal benefit.
- Decline review requests when any personal, professional, financial, competitive, collaborative, or ideological conflict of interest exists.
- Provide objective, unbiased, evidence-based evaluations focused solely on scientific merit.
- Assess manuscripts for originality, scientific validity, methodological rigor, ethical compliance, clarity, and contribution to the field.
- Identify methodological weaknesses, analytical errors, ethical issues, plagiarism, duplicate publication, or inappropriate citations.
- Offer constructive, respectful, and actionable feedback to help authors improve the manuscript.
- Suggest relevant literature or corrections where appropriate.
- Complete reviews within the assigned timeframe and notify the editor immediately if delays are anticipated.
- Avoid personal criticism, maintain professional conduct, and ensure comments are clear and well-justified.
- Support the integrity of the peer-review process by adhering to ethical standards and accountability principles.
- Participate in reviewer engagement activities such as reading guidelines, receiving periodic newsletters, and contributing to quality improvement.
Statistician
- Appointed by the Editor with the approval of the Editorial and Advisory
- Reports directly to the Editor
- Tenure 3 years (renewable)
- Salaried position at comparable market rate
- Minimum qualification-Masters in Statistics / Biostatistics from an HEC-recognized university
Roles and Responsibilities
- Ensure the statistical rigor, validity, and reliability of all manuscripts by evaluating study design, data analysis methods, assumptions, and interpretation of results.
- Confirm that statistical methods are appropriate, accurately applied, and transparently reported, supporting high-quality and ethical scholarly publishing.
- Identify methodological weaknesses, errors, inconsistencies, questionable data patterns, or potential indicators of misconduct and report concerns confidentially to the Editor in accordance with COPE guidelines.
- Promote transparency and reproducibility by encouraging authors to provide detailed statistical methods, raw data, analytical code, and adherence to relevant reporting standards (such as CONSORT, STROBE, PRISMA).
- Provide expert advice to editors on complex statistical issues and assist in decision-making where methodological clarity is essential.
- Offer constructive, unbiased, and evidence-based feedback to authors to improve statistical reporting and strengthen the manuscript’s scientific validity.
- Maintain strict confidentiality of all manuscript content and never use unpublished data for personal or professional gain.
- Declare all conflicts of interest prior to accepting a manuscript for review and recuse yourself when necessary to ensure impartiality.
- Respond promptly to review invitations, may recommend an additional expert statistician depending on the complexity of data, and complete statistical evaluations within designated timelines.
- Uphold COPE, ICMJE, WAME and editorial ethical expectations by supporting accuracy, integrity, and accountability in all statistical evaluations.
- Contribute to maintaining the journal’s compliance with international indexing criteria by ensuring statistical components meet the standards expected for high-impact scholarly publications.
- Support the editorial office in enhancing overall methodological quality through periodic guidance, recommendations, and participation in reviewer or editorial development initiatives.
Editorial Advisory Board
- Members should be distinguished scholars with advanced degrees (Ph.D., M.D. or equivalent) and extensive publication records in fields relevant to the journal.
- Candidates must have demonstrable research impact (high citation metrics, awards or leadership in the field) and recognized expertise in the journal’s subject area.
- The board should include experts from diverse countries and institutions (both national and international members) to ensure a truly global perspective.
- Members’ expertise must align closely with the journal’s thematic scope, covering both core topics and emerging areas of the field to support broad subject coverage.
- Selected individuals should hold reputable academic or professional positions, uphold high ethical standards, and be willing to actively promote and support the journal’s mission
Roles and Responsibilities
- Act purely in a strategic manner (no involvement in peer review or manuscript decisions), providing high-level guidance to strengthen the journal’s profile.
- Offer expert advice on long-term direction, thematic priorities, and emerging research areas to keep the journal academically current and internationally relevant.
- Leverage members’ global networks to promote the journal within the wider research community, enhancing its visibility, indexing, and reputation.
- Connect the editorial team with leading scholars and institutions by recommending special-issue topics, guest editors, qualified reviewers, and high-impact contributors from around the world.
- Advice on ethical standards, publishing best practices, and complex issues (e.g. appeals or research integrity) as requested, thereby reinforcing the journal’s scholarly rigor.
- Serve as ambassadors for the journal by advocating within professional and academic circles, helping to attract diverse, high-quality submissions and collaborations that bolster the journal’s standing.
Last updated: February 2026 Version No: 1
